Exploring Historic New Castle, Delaware: A Step Back in Time

Courthouse

On a sunny Tuesday in September, I set out to explore Historic New Castle, Delaware, a riverside gem that feels like stepping back into colonial times. (Having visited Colonial Williamsburg a number of times, I couldn't wait to see History New Castle.) Known as Delaware’s oldest continuously lived-in town, New Castle was founded in the 1600s and today is often called a living museum. With cobblestone streets, colonial architecture, and stunning views of the Delaware River, it’s a must-visit spot for history lovers and casual travelers alike.

A Town Full of Colonial History

While many of the museums were closed on Tuesday- oops! (few open on Wednesday; most open Saturdays & Sundays), I still enjoyed learning through a self-guided audio tour. By scanning a QR code on the porch of the Old Arsenal Building, now home to the New Castle Historical Society, I was able to listen to stories about specific spots around town and the town’s role in colonial America. Walking along the town green, I imagined life centuries ago when New Castle was a bustling port and gathering place. It was really incredible!

Shepard's Pie

Where to Eat in Historic New Castle

For me, no trip is complete without a good meal, and I found just that at Jessop’s Tavern and Colonial Restaurant, one of the most popular places to eat in Historic New Castle. The restaurant has a cozy, colonial atmosphere with wood-beamed ceilings and period décor.

I tried the much-recommended shepherd’s pie—hearty and comforting, though I wished for a few more vegetables. The highlight, however, was dessert: their English maple walnut ice cream. Sweet, nutty, and delicious, it was the perfect treat after a morning of exploring.

Things to Do in Historic New Castle

Even with most sites closed, there were still plenty of things to see and learn. (I was naive to think I could make it through all 47 sites on the audio tour- I wasn't even close! I'll definitely be back.) I enjoyed walking through the nearby park and taking in the beautiful Delaware River views. The quiet paths and open spaces made it easy to relax and reflect on the deep history surrounding me.

Next time, I plan to return on a weekend when more historic buildings and museums are open. There’s so much more to see—from colonial homes to local exhibits—that I only got a taste of this visit.

Final Thoughts

If you’re looking for a charming 1-2 day trip filled with history, scenic views, and local dining, Historic New Castle, Delaware is the perfect destination. Whether you’re a history buff searching for colonial landmarks, or simply want a peaceful stroll by the river, Historic New Castle has something for everyone. Just be sure to plan your visit on a day when the historic sites are open—and don’t skip dessert at Jessop’s!